Submitted by: Jodi Harding-Kuriger, PhD, HPEC President
What are Meaningful PE experiences?
With gratitude to the student participants and their teachers, we share with you secondary students’ perspectives on Meaningful PE (Fletcher., Ní Chróinín., Gleddie., & Beni, 2021) experiences as described during my recent dissertation research (Harding-Kuriger, 2021). Meaningful PE experiences are co-created by physical educators and students in a democratic learning space and through reflection, both individually and collectively. Secondary students explained what Meaningful PE is for them and how to co-create Meaningful PE experiences. They encourage teachers aiming for Meaningful PE to use the democratic principles of autonomy and inclusivity (Fletcher & Ní Chróinín, 2021) and make time for group and personal reflections.
Who can co-create Meaningful PE experiences?
Democratic educators and autonomous students are the co-creators of Meaningful PE experiences through open dialogue, discussion, and action.
When I think of meaningful physical education I think of good teachers or qualified coaches who know what they are doing. I also think of competitiveness between the students or players, and everyone is involved in the activity that they are doing (Doug, Brainstorming Statements).
Both teachers and students described common preferences for what they like to DO in PE as ‘working hard’ (#7); ‘being active’ (#11); ‘exercising’ (#17); ‘demonstrating sports-personship’ (#29); ‘improving my skills’ (#35); ‘trying my hardest (demonstrating effort)’ (#42); ‘playing sports’ (#38); ‘focusing on the activity’ (#13); ‘being challenged’ (#15); ‘participating in a variety of activities’ (#25); ‘practicing strategies & tactics’ (#22); ‘demonstrating athleticism’ (#28); ‘trying new activities’ (#6); ‘competition’ (#41); ‘being competitive’ (#36); ‘being outdoors’ (#12); and lastly, ‘winning’ (#3) (Figure 1 & Table 1).
Participants also described how they wanted to FEEL in PE as a combination of statements from all four clusters (figure 1): ‘being treated with respect’ (#1); ‘having fun’ (#26); ‘equality’ (#10); ‘being treated with kindness’ (#19); ‘being happy in class’ (#32); ‘having my thoughts and opinions heard’ (#34); ‘making positive memories’ (#27); ‘working hard’ (#7); ‘improving my skills’ (#35); ‘trying my hardest (demonstrating effort)’ (#42); ‘focusing on the activity’ (#13); ‘being challenged’ (#15); ‘including everyone in the activities’ (#18); ‘getting along with others’ (#8); ‘showing support for my classmates’ (#30); ‘everyone demonstrating teamwork’ (#5); ‘group participation’ (#39); ‘laughing with my classmates & teachers’ (#2); and ‘learning’ (#24). Furthermore, student participants acknowledged their personal responsibility for co-creating Meaningful PE experiences: “It is up to us to contribute, like by working hard and putting in the effort and stuff” (Mike, Group 1, Google Meet #4).
Figure 1
Secondary Students’ Meaningful PE Clusters
Table 1 - Secondary Student Identified Meaningful PE Clusters
Beni, S., Fletcher, T., & Ní Chróinín, D. (2017). Meaningful experiences in physical
education and youth sport: A review of the literature, Quest, 69:3, 291 - 312.
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education (Vol. 1938). The Macmillan Co.
Fletcher, T., & Ní Chróinín, D. (2021). Pedagogical principles that support the
prioritisation of meaningful experiences in physical education: conceptual and
practical considerations. Physical education and sport pedagogy. https://doi.org/10.1080/17408989.2021.1884672
Fletcher, T., Ní Chróinín, D., Gleddie, D., & Beni, S. (2021). Meaningful physical
education: An approach for teaching and learning. Routledge
Harding-Kuriger, J. (2021). Conceptualizing meaningful physical education: A secondary
school study. [unpublished Doctoral dissertation, University of Alberta].